Skip to content

Leave Us a Review

Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.


Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.

What our customers say about us...

Profile photo of Angela Porter

Angela Porter

August 28, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Angela Porter
"Just files my first claim with State Farm & the process was simple. Everything from getting the estimate to getting a rental, so easy & clear cut! I had a squirrel chew through my engine harness, worried it wouldn't be covered but it was! Thanks Nick!!"
Profile photo of JoAnn Kelly

JoAnn Kelly

August 28, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by JoAnn Kelly
"Was very nice and helpful"
Profile photo of Jordan Becker

Jordan Becker

August 26, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Jordan Becker
"Nick killed it, made it super easy for me to transfer my car insurance to your team. Completed everything in the matter of 30 minutes. Highly recommend"
Profile photo of Kristi Reller

Kristi Reller

August 26, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Kristi Reller
"Nick has been very professional and a pleasure to work with!"
Profile photo of Carrie Anderson

Carrie Anderson

July 22, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Carrie Anderson
"Very thorough"
We responded:
"Wow - thank you for the amazing 5-star review! It means a lot to our team here in Mendota Hts to know you had such a great experience with us. -Dustin "
Profile photo of martin warren

martin warren

June 26, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by martin warren
"Excellent work on the part of Ben Malloy, agent at Stifter Insurance Agency. Ben listened carefully to all my questions about policies and coverage and then provided me with thorough descriptions of options that would be appropriate to my concerns. That left me feeling confident regarding the choices I finally made. I would definitely recommend Ben and the Stifter Insurance Agency."
We responded:
"Thank you for the kind words Martin. And so happy we are able to help with your auto and home insurance "
Profile photo of Sherri Manz

Sherri Manz

June 19, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Sherri Manz
"Ben has been a great insurance agent to work with! He's been working with me for 2 to 3 months and has never given up on me. He is so kind and helpful! And he saved me a lot of money!"
We responded:
"Thank you so much! Ben is great "
Profile photo of Matti Koivula

Matti Koivula

June 11, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Matti Koivula
"We’ve had a great experience working with this insurance agency. They are knowledgeable, responsive, and always easy to work with. Whenever I call, someone answers the phone… quite rare these days. Highly recommend them to anyone looking for a reliable insurance agency."
We responded:
"Thank you so much for the kind words. So happy we are able to help you with your auto and home insurance needs"
Profile photo of Toby Morgan

Toby Morgan

May 30, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Toby Morgan
"Nick was very helpful, and prompt in helping us find insurance. It is good to have a agent who cares. The reason we left our last was no customer service concern at all."
We responded:
"So happy we were able to help you with your auto and home insurance. And provide great customer service"
Profile photo of Connor O

Connor O

May 29, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Connor O
"He’s been great at helping me understand my options and sourcing good coverage for a good price"
We responded:
"Great to hear and welcome to the agency"
Profile photo of JB Schuessler

JB Schuessler

May 28, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by JB Schuessler
"Great customer service on a call about a claim. Alec responded quickly with all the information I needed. And called me twice to resolve the issue"
We responded:
"great to hear you got amazing service from our team"
Profile photo of Jitesh Kumar

Jitesh Kumar

May 15, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Jitesh Kumar
"They are best!"
We responded:
"Thank you for the kind words!"
Profile photo of Tony Vu

Tony Vu

April 22, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Tony Vu
"Nick was incredibly helpful in getting our homeowners insurance set up and ensuring everything was in place for closing on our new home. He was very communicative throughout the entire process and worked closely with our mortgage lender to make sure all documents were accurate. Everything went smoothly, and his responsiveness and timeliness made a big difference."
We responded:
"So great to hear! Thank you for trusting us for your home and auto insurance needs"
Profile photo of Genesis Davison

Genesis Davison

April 17, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Genesis Davison
"Mary was very informative and quick!"
We responded:
"Thank you for trusting us for your auto insurance needs"
Profile photo of Hugh Casper

Hugh Casper

April 9, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Hugh Casper
"Ben was persistent but not to the point on being a nuisance. He is an excellent agent and one that I hope to continuing using in the future."
We responded:
"Thank you for the kind words! So happy we were able to save you money on your auto insurance "
Profile photo of Bradley Tambor

Bradley Tambor

April 3, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Bradley Tambor
"I learned about Dustin’s office through a friend. Super friendly people, local guys, very personable to work with. Very satisfied!"
We responded:
"Thank you for the great review! So happy we were able to help with your auto and home insurance needs"
Profile photo of Terry Lind

Terry Lind

March 20, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Terry Lind
"Thank you Nick for your great service and getting me reasonable price on auto insurance!"
We responded:
"so great to hear we were able to help save you on your auto insurance needs"
Profile photo of Henry Dalluhn

Henry Dalluhn

March 18, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Henry Dalluhn
"Worked with Alec got a lot of great information and was clear he just wanted to help! I cannot recommend working with this agency more what a fantastic group of professionals."
We responded:
"thank you for the review !"
Profile photo of Tyelin S.

Tyelin S.

March 6, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Tyelin S.
"Love how responsive and informed this team is"
We responded:
"Thank you for trusting us with your insurance needs"
Profile photo of Katelyn Bull

Katelyn Bull

March 3, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Katelyn Bull
"Great customer service"
We responded:
"so happy to hear you have had great customer service"
Profile photo of Hayat Ali

Hayat Ali

March 2, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Hayat Ali
"Super friendly and helpful"
We responded:
"thank you for trusting us with your insurance needs"
Profile photo of Frank Wenszler

Frank Wenszler

February 26, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Frank Wenszler
"Dustin’s team is always eager, knowledgeable and ready to help!!! So much better than who we used to have. I much prefer talking to a person for my insurance rather than a robot."
We responded:
"Thank you for the review. So happy we are able to provide great service"
Profile photo of Ben Malloy

Ben Malloy

February 26, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Ben Malloy
"Saved a lot of money on my home and auto insurance!"
We responded:
"So happy we are able to save you money on your auto and home insurance needs"
Profile photo of Patrick Wallace

Patrick Wallace

February 20, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Patrick Wallace
"Worked with Alec he was very informative and clear with everything"
We responded:
"Glad we were able to help you on your auto insurance needs"
Profile photo of Samantha Buhmann

Samantha Buhmann

February 17, 2026

5  out of  5
rating by Samantha Buhmann
"Mary is the best - highly recommend if you want top tier service, great conversation and a few laughs!! 😁"
We responded:
"So great to hear! Thank you for trusting us with your auto insurance needs"